mystery
60 titles we have read, strongest first. Scored on how the watch went, not how it reviewed.
89Over the Garden Wall 2014
86The Expanse 2015
85Source Code 2011
83The Sixth Sense 1999
83The Bourne Ultimatum 2007
83Dark 2017
82Game Night 2018
82Stranger Things 2016
81Fringe 2008
81Bates Motel 2013
80Memento 2000
80Psycho 1960
80Elementary 2012
80Twin Peaks 1990
79The Prestige 2006
79True Detective 2014
79The Haunting of Hill House 2018
78Twelve Monkeys 1995
78Chinatown 1974
78The Third Man 1949
78L.A. Confidential 1997
78Clue 1985
78Searching 2018
78Lost 2004
78American Gods 2017
77Saw 2004
77Moon Knight 2022
76Gone Girl 2014
76Get Out 2017
76Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery 2025
76Black Mirror 2011
75Lucky Number Slevin 2006
75The Others 2001
75Knives Out 2019
75WandaVision 2021
74Lost Highway 1997
74Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me 1992
74A Nightmare on Elm Street 2010
74The Skin I Live In 2011
74Final Destination Bloodlines 2025
74Pinocchio: Unstrung 2026
73Vertigo 1958
73The Final Destination 2009
72Rear Window 1954
72Oldboy 2003
72Dark City 1998
72Identity 2003
72The Adventures of Tintin 2011
72Pandorum 2009
72Limitless 2011
72American Horror Story 2011
71Contact 1997
71Zodiac 2007
71The Bourne Identity 2002
71Sleepy Hollow 1999
711408 2007
71Shutter Island 2010
71Red Eye 2005
71Watchmen 2009
71The Secret in Their Eyes 2009