I Never Could Love Like That

what happens

With their humanity turned off, Stefan and Caroline begin wreaking havoc at Whitmore, leaving Damon to come up with a risky plan involving Lily. After rushing to help Jo treat victims of Stefan and Caroline’s latest killing spree, Elena discovers Jo is pregnant, prompting her to reevaluate her own life as a vampire. Meanwhile, when Sarah boldly turns the tables on an unsuspecting Enzo, he is forced to open up about his tragic past. Lastly, at Scull Bar, a twisted round of karaoke leaves Tyler and Matt in a dangerous situation.

who made it

directed

Leslie Libman

guest cast

Billed for this episode only — the turn people remember an episode for.

• Annie Wersching as Lily Salvatore
• Jodi Lyn O'Keefe as Jo Laughlin
• Tristin Mays as Sarah Nelson
• Bryan Murphy as Dr. Gabler
• LLane Miller as Bartender
• Gabrielle Byndloss as Female Student